{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the average home price in the U.S. showed a consistent year-over-year increase. However, that trend has come to a halt. Recent data for October reveals that the median home sale price has dipped slightly below last year's level, marking the first year-over-year decline since the spring of 2023. Meanwhile, the housing inventory has reached its highest point since early 2020, pending sales are at their lowest level in over a decade outside of the early pandemic period, and roughly 20% of listings have experienced price reductions.

Nonetheless, the cost of borrowing has risen again. The average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has surged back into the mid-7% range after a short period of improvement. Therefore, even as buyers may find themselves with more bargaining power, the reality of elevated monthly payments remains a challenge for many families.

This situation presents a unique opportunity. Sellers are receiving fewer offers and seeing properties linger on the market longer, which indicates that initial listing prices and sale conditions are becoming more negotiable. If you're hunting for a home this winter, here are some points that might be open for negotiation, along with key considerations to bring up with your agent and lender.

Understanding the slight price reduction

A national decrease of less than half a percent isn't indicative of a market crash nor does it imply that prices are falling uniformly across the board. High-end coastal regions with limited inventory are still experiencing substantial gains, while a number of major cities in the Southern and Western U.S. have seen prices decline by several percentage points compared to last year. The dynamics of your local market hold much more significance than national averages.

The broader trends signal a shift in market dynamics. As homes take longer to sell and inventory competes for fewer interested buyers, sellers tend to become more responsive to negotiations. This flexibility can manifest itself in both price adjustments and the overall terms of the sale.

Exploring options beyond price

Although many buyers concentrate on negotiating the selling price, in a high-interest rate environment, monthly payments and the available cash needed at closing can be even more impactful. A reduction in the purchase price may slightly lower your loan amount, but those funds might yield greater benefits in other areas of your financial plan. Items that buyers often negotiate in a slower market include:

  • A reduced purchase price compared to the listing price
  • Seller credits towards closing costs
  • Repair work completed before finalizing the sale, or a financial credit in lieu of repairs
  • Seller-financed contributions to lower your mortgage rate
  • A closing date that accommodates your schedule
  • Included items such as appliances or window treatments that come with the property

Your real estate agent is well-versed in how local sellers are adjusting and can assist you in prioritizing what to include in your offer. Focus on negotiating for elements that will make the most significant impact on your financial situation.

Utilizing closing cost credits to mitigate expenses

In addition to your down payment, closing costs typically amount to a few percent of the loan value, posing a challenge for many first-time buyers. A seller credit can help alleviate this financial burden by covering some of these costs, thereby lowering the amount you need to bring to the closing meeting.

There are restrictions to consider. Various loan programs limit how much sellers may contribute, usually ranging from 3% to 9% of the sale price, contingent on the loan type and your down payment size. Moreover, credits usually cannot exceed your total actual closing costs. It's essential to consult your lender early on regarding what your specific loan allows to ensure your offer is compliant.

Clarifying the mechanics of a rate buydown

With interest rates climbing above 7%, sellers may be able to assist you through a reduction in your interest rate. There are generally two primary approaches.

A permanent buydown allows you to pay discount points at closing to lower your interest rate for the duration of the loan. Each point costs 1% of the borrowed amount, and the degree of rate reduction varies by lender and market conditions. If you anticipate keeping the loan long-term, a permanent buydown can be a wise investment.

A temporary buydown reduces your payments for the initial year or two. In a common structure, the rate could be two percentage points lower the first year and one point lower the next, before returning to the original rate. For example, on a $350,000 30-year mortgage at approximately 7.34%, monthly principal and interest would be around $2,409. With a temporary buydown in play, the payment for the first year could be reduced to around $1,952, and the second year around $2,176, before returning to the original amount in year three. Covering such an arrangement might cost over $8,000, a sum the seller could consider absorbing instead of opting for a similar price drop.

Keep in mind that while temporary buydowns can alleviate initial financial pressure, they are not permanent solutions. You will need to be prepared for the full payment once the temporary rate reduction concludes. Lenders generally qualify you based on the full rate. Considering potential refinancing options later on if rates decrease is advantageous, although it is impossible to predict exactly when that will occur.

Maintaining inspection protections

In a competitive market, many buyers opted to waive home inspections or limited their request for repairs to strengthen their offers. However, in a slower market, it's less critical to surrender these protections. Conducting a comprehensive inspection provides insight into the condition of the roof, heating and cooling systems, plumbing, electrical, and foundational integrity before you make any commitments.

If the inspection reveals any issues, your agent can guide you on whether to seek repairs, request a price amendment, or ask for credit. Credits may simplify the process, giving you control over who handles the repairs and how, though the right alternative varies based on the problem and the requirements of your mortgage.

Getting your financing squared away

Robust negotiating power is futile without solid financial backing. Sellers comparing two offers typically prefer the one backed by the strongest financial standing. Before you start your property search earnestly, pursue a thorough preapproval instead of a cursory prequalification, understand your maximum comfortable monthly payment as well as your maximum borrowing limit, and evaluate offers from multiple lenders. Check with each lender about their procedures regarding seller credits or buydowns to sidestep surprises later.

Key questions for your agent

  • What's the average time homes spend on the market here, and how frequently are prices adjusted?
  • Which option would better suit my budget: a price reduction, a closing cost credit, or a rate buydown?
  • How does the condition and history of this specific property influence what I might request?
  • What contingencies should I include in my offer to safeguard my interests?

Final thoughts

While a softening market may not eliminate expenses, particularly with rising mortgage rates, it does provide informed buyers with increased opportunities to negotiate terms more favorable to their financial situation. With solid financing, a clear understanding of your priorities, and the support of your agent and lender, you may find yourself securing terms that were unimaginable just a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI

Floating Icon